
At CHF 1,900 of costs, franchise 300 means you pay 300 plus 10% of 1,600, so CHF 460 on top of the premium. Franchise 2,500 means you pay all 1,900. The difference is CHF 1,440, close to the CHF 1,432 premium saving, so the two cost the same. At CHF 7,800 the gap flips: franchise 300 totals CHF 6,935, franchise 2,500 totals CHF 7,533, so 300 wins by CHF 598.
Each franchise step gives roughly the same premium discount, while your own cost grows with the first francs of every bill. A franchise of 1,000 or 1,500 gives only part of the discount and still leaves you most of the risk. In the published comparison, the intermediate levels lost in every scenario tested. The cheapest insurer can also change with the franchise, so rerun the comparison for each level.