---
title: "Pillar 3a: account or securities?: 30 years, three outcomes"
slate: "Pillar 3a: account or securities?"
page: "30 years, three outcomes"
url: "https://slatesource.com/@swiss_money_basics/pillar-3a-account-or-securities/30-years-three-outcomes"
author: "Swiss_Money_Basics"
type: "ARTICLE"
created: "2026-11-18T23:30:59.823+00:00"
updated: "2026-11-18T23:40:24.738+00:00"
---

![Pillar 3a: account or securities?](https://cdn.slatesource.com/c/5/c/c5ce5486-04da-4b97-bb99-0152317c5282.webp)

# Pillar 3a: account or securities?

- [Made in Slatesource](https://slatesource.com/@swiss_money_basics/pillar-3a-account-or-securities)
- By [Swiss_Money_Basics](https://slatesource.com/@swiss_money_basics)
- Created on Nov 18, 2026

## Pages

- 30 years, three outcomes (this page)
- [What accounts pay](https://slatesource.com/@swiss_money_basics/pillar-3a-account-or-securities/what-accounts-pay.md)
- [Securities: cost and risk](https://slatesource.com/@swiss_money_basics/pillar-3a-account-or-securities/securities-cost-and-risk.md)

<!-- chip:bar-chart #chf-500-a-month-for-30-years-final-balance-in-chf -->
## CHF 500 a month for 30 years, final balance in CHF [#chf-500-a-month-for-30-years-final-balance-in-chf](https://slatesource.com/@swiss_money_basics/pillar-3a-account-or-securities/30-years-three-outcomes#chf-500-a-month-for-30-years-final-balance-in-chf)

| Label | Value |
|---|---|
| Account at 0.05% | 181353 |
| Account at 1% | 209666 |
| Securities at 5.5% net (theory) | 445000 |

Links: [moneyland.ch](https://www.moneyland.ch/de/saeule-3a-zinsen-analyse-2026)

<!-- chip:info #the-gap-is-the-point-and-so-is-the-risk -->
## The gap is the point, and so is the risk [#the-gap-is-the-point-and-so-is-the-risk](https://slatesource.com/@swiss_money_basics/pillar-3a-account-or-securities/30-years-three-outcomes#the-gap-is-the-point-and-so-is-the-risk)

Moneyland (15 Oct 2026) calculated these three cases. Even the best account pays only about CHF 28,000 more than the worst over 30 years. The 5.5% case is a projection, not a promise: Moneyland itself notes the amount can end up far lower if markets do badly. The tax saving is the same in all cases, so the choice is only about return, risk and cost.

Links: [moneyland.ch](https://www.moneyland.ch/de/saeule-3a-zinsen-analyse-2026)

<!-- chip:note #c-f361e99d -->
> [!NOTE]
> Annual maximum and tax advantage are identical for account, securities and insurance (Vermoegenszentrum, updated 2 Jan 2026).