---
title: "Book Club Questions: In This Life or Another"
slate: "Book Club Questions: In This Life or Another"
page: "Home"
url: "https://slatesource.com/@pagebound/book-club-questions-in-this-life-or-another"
author: "pagebound"
category: "Education & Learning"
type: "BOOK"
created: "2026-11-16T11:49:20.573+00:00"
updated: "2026-11-16T11:51:33.024+00:00"
---

![Book Club Questions: In This Life or Another](https://cdn.slatesource.com/a/a/d/aad09e86-e02b-4818-a9ca-28cd99c821c7.webp)

# Book Club Questions: In This Life or Another

- [Made in Slatesource](https://slatesource.com/@pagebound/book-club-questions-in-this-life-or-another)
- By [pagebound](https://slatesource.com/@pagebound)
- Education & Learning
- Created on Nov 16, 2026

## What this page gives your club [#what-this-page-gives-your-club](https://slatesource.com/@pagebound/book-club-questions-in-this-life-or-another#what-this-page-gives-your-club)

Ten original questions, one poll to pick your opener, and a page you can share with your group. Voting needs a free Slatesource account.

## Spoiler note and how to use this page [#spoiler-note-and-how-to-use-this-page](https://slatesource.com/@pagebound/book-club-questions-in-this-life-or-another#spoiler-note-and-how-to-use-this-page)

In This Life or Another is a novel by Melissa Payne, published in September 2026 (317 pages). Public premise: on the eve of his sixtieth birthday, mechanic Rusty Wilson is shot while protecting the people in a small Colorado diner, and wakes in a place between life and death where he can look at the life he had and another one he might have had. Part 1 uses only that premise, so it is safe before you read. Parts 2 and 3 are for after the book. These questions are original and not taken from any publisher or other guide.

## Part 1: before or while you read (premise only, no spoilers) [#part-1-before-or-while-you-read-premise-only-no-spoilers](https://slatesource.com/@pagebound/book-club-questions-in-this-life-or-another#part-1-before-or-while-you-read-premise-only-no-spoilers)

1\. A man protects strangers without time to think. What do you believe people do in that moment: choose, or reveal who they already are? 2. Rusty thinks his life held more disappointment than joy. Is turning sixty the age when people take that kind of count? 3. If you could look at the life you did not live, would you want to? What would you hope to find, and what would you fear? 4. The book asks what makes a life meaningful. Give your own answer in one sentence before you read, then compare at the end.

## Part 2: after you finish (spoilers ahead) [#part-2-after-you-finish-spoilers-ahead](https://slatesource.com/@pagebound/book-club-questions-in-this-life-or-another#part-2-after-you-finish-spoilers-ahead)

5\. The book offers Rusty a look at another life. Did it feel like a gift, a test, or a trap? Did your answer change as you read? 6. The story deals with a family secret and with estrangement. Which was harder to forgive in the book, silence or a deliberate choice? 7. Did the love Rusty held from a distance feel like a missed chance or a story he told himself? Make your case. 8. The setting between life and death is a big idea in a small town book. Did the two sit well together for your group?

## Part 3: bring it home [#part-3-bring-it-home](https://slatesource.com/@pagebound/book-club-questions-in-this-life-or-another#part-3-bring-it-home)

9\. Which one decision would you change if you were offered the other path? Would you really change it? 10. Who in your life would you want to be at the table of a book club on this book? Why that person? 11. Whom would you hand this book to: a reader in grief, a reader who loves second chance stories, or someone else?

## Which question should we open with? [#c-02b5bd89](https://slatesource.com/@pagebound/book-club-questions-in-this-life-or-another#c-02b5bd89)

journey·3 Parts

# How our group felt, part by part (sample entries, replace with yours) [#how-our-group-felt-part-by-part-sample-entries-replace-with](https://slatesource.com/@pagebound/book-club-questions-in-this-life-or-another#how-our-group-felt-part-by-part-sample-entries-replace-with)

Group score

/

Part

"Sample note: warm start, big question

"Sample note: we split on the other life

"Sample note: the one decision question ran an hour

## Run your own club page [#run-your-own-club-page](https://slatesource.com/@pagebound/book-club-questions-in-this-life-or-another#run-your-own-club-page)

Pagebound makes pages like this one. Join Slatesource with our creator link: https://slatesource.com/join/PAGEBOUND (creator code PAGEBOUND gives 10 percent off in the shop). Poll and journey chips come with the Reader Pack.

[Join with our creator link](https://slatesource.com/join/PAGEBOUND)

Suggest a question

Got a better question for this book? Send it and we will add it to the list.

## More reader pages [#more-reader-pages](https://slatesource.com/@pagebound/book-club-questions-in-this-life-or-another#more-reader-pages)

Other free pages from the same team: a reading challenge, a year in books page and more book club question sets. They are shown below.

[

![Reading Challenge 2027, Poll and Track](https://cdn.slatesource.com/f/8/1/f810145c-3e66-41c6-8e3b-7280225cfc5b.webp)

Reading Challenge 2027, Poll and TrackBy pagebound

](/@pagebound/reading-challenge-2027-poll-and-track)

[

![Book Club Questions: Theo of Golden](https://cdn.slatesource.com/5/3/b/53b57d7f-8b2b-47bd-9da3-dc43fd4038c6.webp)

Book Club Questions: Theo of GoldenBy pagebound

](/@pagebound/book-club-questions-theo-of-golden)

[

![Reading Wrapped 2026: Your Year in Books](https://cdn.slatesource.com/4/6/4/464c510e-ed18-42a2-a323-da450a6dfb32.webp)

Reading Wrapped 2026: Your Year in BooksBy pagebound

](/@pagebound/reading-wrapped-2026-your-year-in-books)

[

![Book Club Questions: Peregrine Hill](https://cdn.slatesource.com/f/a/8/fa872750-cfb3-4f5d-943a-539ad88d87b7.webp)

Book Club Questions: Peregrine HillBy pagebound

](/@pagebound/book-club-questions-peregrine-hill)

[

![Book Club Questions: The Natural Order](https://cdn.slatesource.com/3/8/1/38116ed0-1ce9-40ee-832b-a8c7575e3216.webp)

Book Club Questions: The Natural OrderBy pagebound

](/@pagebound/book-club-questions-the-natural-order)

[

![Our Book Club Reading List, Vote Next Book](https://cdn.slatesource.com/7/1/c/71cec69f-3e6c-436f-9ccc-b4215fbe3ef2.webp)

Our Book Club Reading List, Vote Next BookBy pagebound

](/@pagebound/our-book-club-reading-list-vote-next-book)