Slatesource
PrivacyTerms© 2026 Slatesource
Annie Hall: A Murder Mystery Rebuilt In The Edit

Annie Hall: A Murder Mystery Rebuilt In The Edit

Annie Hall (1977)

It was shot as a story about a man's inner life called Anhedonia, and became a romantic comedy on the cutting room floor.

Runtime

93 minutes

Director

Woody Allen

Budget

$4 million

Box office

$38.3 million worldwide

Cinematography

Gordon Willis

"

I would never want to belong to any club that would have someone like me for a member.

"

Alvy Singer · Annie Hall · 1977

Found In The Edit

The film Allen shot was a sprawl about a comedian's consciousness, complete with a murder plot and fantasy sequences, provisionally titled Anhedonia. In the cutting room with Ralph Rosenblum it became clear that every section involving the relationship worked and most of the rest did not, so they threw out the plot and rebuilt the picture around Alvy and Annie. What survives of the original ambition is the freedom of the form: direct address to camera, split screens of two families eating dinner, subtitles printing what the characters actually mean, an animated sequence, a queue of strangers asked to settle an argument, and a man pulling Marshall McLuhan out of frame to win a point about Fellini.

journey·6 Acts

Watching Annie Hall

Dread

/

Act

12345
Two Jokes
Confided
"A comedian addresses the camera with two old jokes about misery and love and explains that the relationship is over."

Diane Keaton's real surname is Hall and her nickname was Annie, and much of the wardrobe that started a decade of menswear on women was her own clothing brought to set.

It beat Star Wars to Best Picture in 1978. Allen did not attend the ceremony, playing his regular Monday jazz set in New York instead.