

Devices tested
7 (4 worn, 3 bedside)
Healthy adults, nights in the lab
34, 3 nights
Sleep detected correctly
over 93%
Wake detected correctly
18% to 54%
Chinoy and colleagues, in the journal Sleep in 2021, had 34 healthy young adults spend three nights in a sleep laboratory. Each wore consumer trackers and a research actigraphy watch while a full sleep recording, polysomnography, served as the reference. Four of the seven devices were worn on the body and three sat by the bed. Most matched or beat the actigraphy watch at telling sleep from wake.
Thirty-four healthy young adults over three nights is a small, specific group, and the devices have since been updated. The pattern, good at sleep and weak at wake, is the useful part. Exact percentages will differ for your device and your sleep.